Tucked into the rolling hills of Mulmur, Heaven-on-Fifth feels like a storybook brought to life. This remarkable nine-bedroom Victorian farmhouse has been thoughtfully reimagined into a refined modern country retreat, blending timeless charm with elevated design. Whether you're seeking a private family escape, an income-generating opportunity, or a forever home, this property offers exceptional versatility.A winding drive carries you through mature forest, across a gentle river and past a tranquil private pond, revealing a serene setting surrounded by Annabelle hydrangeas and towering trees. Inside, warm pine floors, exposed beams, and expansive open-concept living spaces create an inviting atmosphere ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Enjoy formal living and dining rooms, a beautifully updated kitchen, a large family room, and an impressive games room with a built-in wet bar.The second level features a peaceful primary suite with a walk-in closet, spa-inspired open shower, and private water closet, alongside three additional bedrooms and a four-piece bath. The third floor offers a secondary suite with ensuite plus a flexible bedroom or office. The lower level completes the home with three additional bedrooms.Outdoors, a cedar deck with a built-in hot tub and multiple dining areas overlooks a new saltwater pool, creating a true resort-style experience. With year-round amenities including a games room and gym, this turnkey property is equally suited as a recreational retreat, full-time residence, or destination investment.Ideally located just 80 minutes from Toronto, minutes to Mansfield Ski Club, and close to Creemore, Mad River Golf Club, and Collingwood, Heaven-on-Fifth offers privacy without compromise. A truly one-of-a-kind opportunity to live, host, and unwind.
Property Highlights
For Sale
MLS NO.
X12911736
Type
Residential Freehold
Sub Type
Detached
Bedrooms
9
Bathrooms
5
Parking
21.0
Garage
Yes
Complete Property Details
Property Type
Residential Freehold
Sub Type
Detached
Transaction Type
For Sale
Status
Closed
Contract Status
Unavailable
MLS® Number
X12911736
Living Area Range
3500-5000
Total Bedrooms
9
Bedrooms Above Grade
6
Bedrooms Below Grade
3
Total Bathrooms
5
Total Kitchens
1
Kitchens Above Grade
1
Rooms Above Grade
13
Rooms Below Grade
3
Interior Features
Water Heater Owned
Fireplace
Yes
Central Vacuum Yn
No
Construction
Board & Batten
Roof
Asphalt Shingle
Lot Width
403.4
Parking Features
Private
Parking Total
21.0
Covered Spaces
1.0
Garage Type
Detached
Garage
Yes
Pool
Inground, Salt
Direction Facing
West
Cooling
Central Air
Heat Source
Propane
Heat Type
Forced Air
Internet Address Display Yn
Yes
Internet Entire Listing Display Yn
Yes
Full Address
876382 5th Line, Mulmur, ON L9V 0J9
City
Mulmur
Neighbourhood
Rural Mulmur
County / Region
Dufferin
Province / State
ON
Postal Code
L9V 0J9
Cross Street
Airport Rd/5th Sdrd/5th Line
Directions
Airport Rd/5th Sdrd/5th Line
Country
CA
List Price
$2,349,000
Annual Taxes
$8,050
Tax Year
2025
Legal Description
PT LT 7, CON 5 EHS AS IN MF90557; T/W MF216234 ; MULMUR
Possession Type
Flexible
Possession Details
Immediate/TBD
Listing Office
PROPERTY.CA INC.
Board
Toronto Regional Real Estate Board
Original Entry
2026-03-23T20:19:27Z
Media Updated
2026-06-01T17:33:20Z
Photos Updated
2026-06-01T17:33:20Z
Last Modified
2026-06-08T21:50:57Z
System Modified
2026-07-06T21:33:15.365173Z
MLS Status
Sold
Architectural Style
2 1/2 Storey
Basement
Finished
Co List Office Name
PROPERTY.CA INC.
Ddfyn
Yes
Expiration Date
2026-09-30
Foundation Details
Concrete
Heat Source Multi
Propane
Heat Type Multi
Forced Air
Hstapplication
Included In
Link Yn
No
Occupant Type
Owner
Originating System Id
A00001796
Parking Spaces
20
Public Remarks
Tucked into the rolling hills of Mulmur, Heaven-on-Fifth feels like a storybook brought to life. This remarkable nine-bedroom Victorian farmhouse has been thoughtfully reimagined into a refined modern country retreat, blending timeless charm with elevated design. Whether you're seeking a private family escape, an income-generating opportunity, or a forever home, this property offers exceptional versatility.A winding drive carries you through mature forest, across a gentle river and past a tranquil private pond, revealing a serene setting surrounded by Annabelle hydrangeas and towering trees. Inside, warm pine floors, exposed beams, and expansive open-concept living spaces create an inviting atmosphere ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Enjoy formal living and dining rooms, a beautifully updated kitchen, a large family room, and an impressive games room with a built-in wet bar.The second level features a peaceful primary suite with a walk-in closet, spa-inspired open shower, and private water closet, alongside three additional bedrooms and a four-piece bath. The third floor offers a secondary suite with ensuite plus a flexible bedroom or office. The lower level completes the home with three additional bedrooms.Outdoors, a cedar deck with a built-in hot tub and multiple dining areas overlooks a new saltwater pool, creating a true resort-style experience. With year-round amenities including a games room and gym, this turnkey property is equally suited as a recreational retreat, full-time residence, or destination investment.Ideally located just 80 minutes from Toronto, minutes to Mansfield Ski Club, and close to Creemore, Mad River Golf Club, and Collingwood, Heaven-on-Fifth offers privacy without compromise. A truly one-of-a-kind opportunity to live, host, and unwind.
